Robert T. Rhode

Robert T. Rhode
Robert T. Rhode

Tuesday, March 1, 2016

Mysteries of Warren County, Indiana: J. Frank Hanly



“He remains one of Indiana's most controversial governors.” So Wikipedia summarizes the public service of James Frank Hanly, the 26th Governor of Indiana from 1905 to 1909. “J. Frank” was from Williamsport, the county seat of Warren County. I grew up in Pine Village, a town in the same county.

What made Hanly so controversial? We will soon see.

J. Frank Hanly
Governor of Indiana from 1905 to 1909

Born in a log cabin in Champaign County, Illinois, in 1863, Hanly was the youngest of seven children. He attended a rural school near Homer. Eventually, he enrolled in Danville’s Eastern Illinois Normal School. He moved to Warren County, Indiana, and taught public school. Married to Eva A. R. Simmer in 1881, Hanly studied law and entered Judge Joseph M. Rabb’s law office in Williamsport in 1889. Of the Hanlys’ five children, only one lived beyond childhood.

Hanly served in the Indiana State Senate. He won election to a term in the U.S. House of Representatives. In 1899, he ran unsuccessfully for the U.S. Senate. Hanly delivered fiery, sanctimonious speeches to defeat his Democratic rival and to become Governor. In Indianapolis, he charted his own course without conforming to the wishes of the Republican Party that had nominated him. He championed temperance and prohibition and warred against such corruption as gambling. He worked to ensure that government offices would perform their functions in a non-partisan manner. He required the state to begin keeping accurate financial records. It was during his administration that Indiana mandated sterilization of various individuals in custody, but the law was overturned two years later. Hanly put many state officials on trial for embezzlement.

While Hanly was Governor, public officials were caught paying gambling debts with government expense accounts at French Lick’s resort hotel, which was owned by Thomas Taggart, chair of the Democratic National Committee. Hanly authorized the state police to raid French Lick, where slot machines, roulette wheels, and other gambling paraphernalia were seized. The suit that Hanly brought against Taggart became bogged down until it was dropped after a Democratic governor was elected.

After his governorship, Hanly lectured on prohibition. He became the Prohibition Party’s candidate for President of the United States in the 1916 election, receiving approximately 1.2 percent of the vote; President Woodrow Wilson was elected to a second term. In 1920, Hanly won a case before the U.S. Supreme Court upholding the Eighteenth Amendment, which prohibited the sale of alcoholic beverages. Through a public referendum, Ohio had tried to overturn the amendment. On a speaking tour during the same year, Hanly passed away from injuries received when a Pennsylvania freight train struck the automobile in which he was a passenger near Dennison, Ohio. He lies buried at Hillside Cemetery in Williamsport. In keeping with his morality, his marker is understated.

Hanly’s public life can be summarized in the noun “crusader”: hence, his status as a controversial figure!  

No comments:

Post a Comment